Survivor: Prison Island
Survivor prison island logo by crazypackersfan-d698ojq
Season Run June 26th, 2013 - August 27th, 2013
Location Prison Island
Episodes 14
Survivors 21
Days 39
Winner Barbara 'Batgirl' Gordon
Runner-up(s) Pepper Clark
Tribes ██ Ontar
██ Zeusch
Blood vs. Water Pepper, Diddy
Unfinished Business Lobo, NiGHTS, Zod
Battle Royale Pepper, Skarlet
Last Chances Midna, Lobo
Final Showdown Batgirl
Series Chronology
Previous Season Destiny Isles
Next Season Packers

Survivor: Prison Island is the nineteenth season of BambiTJ93's fanfic version of the reality television series Survivor, which premiered on June 26th, 2013. Read the season here!

The show premiered on June 26th, 2013 at 8pm with a special 90-minute premiere, then returned to its normal hour-long format in the following week.

This season was described as having many, many twists. The first of which being returning players being voted in by viewers. Kasumi from Survivor: Forest Maze, Survivor: Virmire, and Survivor: Ultimates, Knuckles from Survivor: SEGA All Stars, Midna from Survivor: Cuties, and No-Face from Survivor: Redemption Island. Along with the returning players, the two tribes have to live together on the same beach, in a One World setting.

The main twists of the season included switching tribes at every reward challenge, and when the remaining players are odd-numbered, one player will be imprisoned, stuck on Prison Island until the next reward challenge.

Similar to Connie from Survivor: Marble, contestant Jeff the Killer hid his identity, using dark sunglasses and a scarf to cover his face. He revealed his identity to Pepper to gain her trust. Unlike Connie, Jeff wasn't part of a twist.

A new twist of the season included Bill, and his identical twin Ben. On odd days, Bill would be the twin, while on even days, Ben would be the twin. They would both play Bill's game until a certain point in the game, in which both twins would get to play their own games. On Episode 8, Ben was officially made into a player due to Skarlet's sudden medical evacuation due to a poisonous scorpion sting.

Batgirl was named the winner in the final episode on August 27th, 2013, defeating Pepper and Rarity in a 5-4-0 vote. Pepper also won $100,000 as the "Sprint Player of the Season", narrowly beating out Batgirl and Diddy.

Pepper and Diddy both returned for Survivor: Blood vs. Water. Pepper's boyfriend Sunil, and Diddy's girlfriend Dixie came with them as part of the twist. In addition, Sunil was originally casted for Prison Island, but cut. Both Sunil and Pepper were booted back to back, with Sunil placing 10th, and Pepper placing 9th. Diddy was booted 11th, while Dixie ultimately won the season.

Lobo, NiGHTS, and Zod all returned to play again in Survivor: Unfinished Business. All three players were eliminated back to back, with Lobo placing 10th due to the purple rock, and Zod and NiGHTS being booted after and placing 9th and 8th.

Bad Girls Syndicate members Pepper and Skarlet would return to play the game together again in Survivor: Battle Royale. They would place 6th and 13th respectively.

Lobo and Midna would both return for their third chance in Survivor: Last Chances. Midna ended up placing 22nd, while Lobo placed 14th.

Etna, Grune, Heath, Jess, Moses, Presea, Rachel, Roy, Shohn, Sindel, Stepney, and Sub-Zero were included on the viewer poll, but did not receive the votes needed to return. Kattlelox Island player Wave, and Lake Hylia player Waluigi were both casted to appear on this season as well, but were cut during the casting process.



Ontar: Zod, No-Face, Kasumi, Scorpion, Lobo, Pepper, NiGHTS, Skarlet, Freddy Krueger, Diddy
Zeusch: Minka, Midna, Edward, Jeff the Killer, Bill & Ben, Batgirl, Slenderman, Knuckles, Lanky, Rarity

Contestant Original
Swapped Tribes
(By Episode)
Finish Total Votes
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Zod2 BW Zod
DC Comics
Ontar 1st Voted Out
Day 3
Minka BW Minka
Littlest Pet Shop
Zeusch O 2nd Voted Out
Day 6
Slenderman BW Slenderman
Zeusch Z O 3rd Voted Out
Day 9
Lanky Kong BW Lanky
Donkey Kong 64
Zeusch O O O 4th Voted Out
Day 11
Freddy Krueger BW Freddy
A Nightmare On Elm
Ontar O Z Z 5th Voted Out
Day 11
Scorpion2 BW Scorpion
Mortal Kombat
Ontar O Z Z Z 6th Voted Out
Day 14
Knuckles BW Knuckles
Sonic the Hedgehog
SEGA All Stars
Zeusch Z Z O O O 7th Voted Out
Day 17
NiGHTS Into Dreams
Ontar Z O O O O Z 8th Voted Out
Day 19
Lobo M BW Lobo
DC Comics
Ontar Z Z Z P Z Z 9th Voted Out
Day 19
Skarlet BW Skarlet
Mortal Kombat
Ontar Z O Z Z Z O Removed Due to Illness
1st Jury Member
Day 20
Kasumi BW Kasumi
Mass Effect
Forest Maze, Virmire, &
Ontar O O O O O O O 10th Voted Out
2nd Jury Member
Day 22
No-Face BW No-Face
Twisted Metal Black
Redemption Island
Ontar Z Z O O Z O O Z 11th Voted Out
3rd Jury Member
Day 25
Edward BW Edward
Thomas & Friends
Zeusch O O P Z Z Z Z Z Z 12th Voted Out
4th Jury Member
Day 27
Diddy Kong BW Diddy
Donkey Kong Country
Ontar P O O O O Z Z O Z BRVR 13th Voted Out
5th Jury Member
Day 30
Bill 2 BW Ben
Thomas & Friends
Zeusch O Z Z Z O O O Z O 14th Voted Out
6th Jury Member
Day 33
Midna BW Midna
Legend of Zelda
Zeusch Z O Z Z Z O P O O 15th Voted Out
7th Jury Member
Day 36
Bill BW Bill
Thomas & Friends
Zeusch O Z Z Z O O O O O 16th Voted Out
8th Jury Member
Day 37
Jeff the Killer BW Jeff the Killer
Zeusch O Z Z Z O O O O P 17th Voted Out
9th Jury Member
Day 38
Rarity BW Rarity
My Little Pony
Zeusch Z Z O O Z P Z O Z 2nd Runner Up 4
Pepper BW Pepper
Littlest Pet Shop
Ontar O O Z Z O Z Z Z Z Runner Up 10
Batgirl colored Batgirl
DC Comics
Zeusch Z Z O O Z Z Z Z O Sole Survivor 5
The Total Votes is the number of votes a castaway has received during Tribal Councils where the castaway is eligible to be voted out of the game. It does not include the votes received during the final Tribal Council.

The gameEdit

Episode Challenges Imprisoned Eliminated Vote Finish
Reward Immunity
"Anti-Hero Role"
- Kasumi
Zeusch None Zod 6-4 1st Voted Out
Day 3
"Luck Always Runs Out"
- Lanky
Ontar Zeusch Diddy Minka 5-4 2nd Voted Out
Day 6
"Pawn In The Plan"
- Knuckles
Ontar Zeusch None Slenderman 8-1 3rd Voted Out
Day 9
"You Dare Mock Me?"
- Freddy Krueger
Ontar None Edward Lanky 6-2 4th Voted Out
Day 11
Freddy 5-3 5th Voted Out
Day 11
"Little Something Extra"
- Lobo
Ontar Ontar Lobo Scorpion 6-1 6th Voted Out
Day 14
"Could Spell Disaster"
- Rarity
Zeusch Zeusch None Knuckles 5-2 7th Voted Out
Day 17
"Boom Goes The Dynamite"
- Midna
None Batgirl Rarity NiGHTS 5-3-2-2 8th Voted Out
Day 19
Bill Lobo 9th Voted Out
Day 19
"Who Can Ignore Me?"
- Jeff the Killer
Ontar Zeusch Midna Skarlet No vote Removed Due to Illness
1st Jury Member
Day 20
Kasumi 3-2 10th Voted Out
2nd Jury Member
Day 22
"The Polite Godfather"
- Batgirl
Ontar Ontar None No-Face 4-1 11th Voted Out
3rd Jury Member
Day 25
"Wrapped Around His Funnel"
- Jeff the Killer
Ontar Jeff Edward 2-1-1 12th Voted Out
4th Jury Member
Day 27
"No Such Thing As Outchallenge"
- Rarity
Bill, Jeff,
Pepper None Diddy 5-3 13th Voted Out
5th Jury Member
Day 30
"A Never Break Apart Duo"
- Rarity
Auction Jeff Ben 1-0 14th Voted Out
6th Jury Member
Day 33
"Bathing In Cold Cash"
- Rarity
Bill [Jeff,
Bill Midna 4-2 15th Voted Out
7th Jury Member
Day 36
"Finale" None Batgirl Bill 4-1 16th Voted Out
8th Jury Member
Day 37
Batgirl Jeff 3-1 17th Voted Out
9th Jury Member
Day 38
"Reunion" Jury Vote Rarity 5-4-0 2nd Runner Up
Pepper Runner Up
Batgirl Sole Survivor

Voting historyEdit

Swapping Tribes Merged Tribe
Episode #: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Eliminated: Zod
6/10 votes
5/9 votes
8/9 votes
6/8 votes
5/8 votes
6/7 votes
5/7 votes
NiGHTS / Lobo
8/12 votes
No vote
3/5 votes
4/5 votes
2/4 votes
5/8 votes
1/1 vote
4/6 votes
4/5 votes
3/4 votes
Batgirl Lanky Lobo No-Face Diddy Midna Midna Bill Jeff
Pepper Zod Minka Slenderman Freddy Scorpion Knuckles NiGHTS No-Face Edward Diddy Midna Midna Bill Jeff
Rarity Lanky Edward Batgirl Ben Midna Bill Jeff
Jeff Minka Freddy Scorpion Knuckles NiGHTS No-Face Diddy Midna Midna Bill Rarity
Bill Kasumi Freddy Scorpion Knuckles NiGHTS Kasumi Diddy Midna Batgirl Pepper
Midna Slenderman Freddy Scorpion Kasumi Batgirl Ben Batgirl
Ben Twin Twist Kasumi No-Face Diddy Midna
Diddy Zod Slenderman Rarity Knuckles NiGHTS Rarity Batgirl
Edward Kasumi Slenderman Scorpion NiGHTS No-Face Pepper
No-Face Zod Lanky Diddy Kasumi Pepper
Kasumi Zod Minka Slenderman Lanky Knuckles Lobo No-Face
Skarlet Zod Slenderman Freddy Scorpion Lobo
Lobo Pepper Pepper Kasumi
NiGHTS Zod Slenderman Lanky Kasumi Diddy
Knuckles Lanky Kasumi
Scorpion Pepper Minka Pepper Skarlet
Freddy Pepper Minka Pepper
Lanky Kasumi Slenderman Rarity
Slenderman Lanky
Minka Kasumi
Zod Pepper
Jury vote
Finalist: Rarity
0/9 votes
4/9 votes
5/9 votes
Juror Vote
Jeff Pepper
Bill Pepper
Midna Batgirl
Ben Pepper
Diddy Batgirl
Edward Pepper
No-Face Batgirl
Kasumi Batgirl
Skarlet Batgirl


The Season: Despite having a lot of twists, Prison Island actually managed to be a high tier season. There were many memorable players, good choices for returning players, and amazing blindsides. The advantage twist also worked well despite some concerns.

The Winner: Batgirl worked hard in the game, and is considered a great winner, probably the first great female winner in the series. She was in a great alliance, she played both sides early on well, and managed to get the votes to win over the lovable Pepper.

Survivor Seasons (Series 1)
2010: Green Hill · SEGA All Stars · Emerald Hill · Reals vs. OCs · All-Stars · Koopa Beach · Cuties · Marble
2011: Fans vs. Favorites · Distant · Heroes vs. Villains · Redemption Island · Aquatic Ruin
2012: Forest Maze · Virmire · Ultimates
2013: Edenia · Destiny Isles · Prison Island · Packers · Blood vs. Water
2014: Kattlelox Island · Unfinished Business · Singapore · Yoshi Desert · Lake Hylia
2015: Beach Bowl Galaxy · Battle Royale · Dingo Canyon · Pirate Lagoon
2016: Waterfall · Last Chances · Final Showdown

Characters (C) Nintendo / Sega / Netherrealm Studios / Bioware / Sony Computer Entertainment / Hasbro Inc. / DC Comics / HiT Entertainment / New Line Cinema

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.